The New York Times
Late in Life, Finding a Bonanza in Life Insurance
By CHARLES DUHIGG
Published: December 17, 2006
Marvin Margolis, an 80-year-old Manhattan financial consultant,
is looking for investors willing to bet on when he will die.
Golden Opportunities
Cashing In
Articles in this series will examine how businesses and
investors seek to profit from the soaring number of older Americans, in ways
helpful and harmful.
Two years ago, Mr. Margolis bought a large life insurance
policy. Now, he’s considering selling it to a group of investors, a deal that
should give him as much as $2 million to enjoy in his final years. In return,
the investors will get the policy’s $7 million payout when he dies — which they
hope will be soon, so they can stop paying his premiums.
“This is a wonderful opportunity to use my body as an asset,”
Mr. Margolis said. “I deserve to be able to benefit in some way from my age.”
Trading in life insurance policies held by wealthy seniors has
quietly become a big business. Hedge funds, financial institutions like Credit
Suisse and Deutsche Bank, and investors like Warren E. Buffett are spending
billions to buy life insurance policies from the elderly. Other investors are
paying seniors to apply for life insurance, lending them money to buy the
policies, and then reselling them to speculators.
This nascent market illustrates one way that investors are
hoping to make money from a large and wealthy generation of Americans as they
reach retirement age. These aging baby boomers and those even older offer both
opportunities and risks for many companies, investors and swindlers seeking to
capitalize on their final years.
Insurance executives, for instance, say transactions like Mr.
Margolis’s may cripple their industry and make it harder for the average senior
to buy life insurance in the first place. Insurers are worried because they
count on many customers canceling their policies before they die, usually
because their children grow up and no longer need the financial protection,
their pensions kick in or premiums become too expensive. If far more policies
result in payouts, the insurance business becomes much less profitable.
Indeed, industry analysts say they expect the cost of life
insurance to rise as companies prepare to pay out more claims.
“If payouts increase, the cost of insuring people is effectively
going up, and that will definitely increase the price of policies,” said J.
David Cummins, a professor at the Wharton School of the University of
Pennsylvania.
While that may be the case, many people have come to rely on
selling their policies to provide urgently needed money for medical care and
living expenses when their bank accounts run dry. However, insurance executives
say that the market that has emerged could be ruinous.
“Life insurance is a way for individuals to protect their
families,” said C. Robert Henrikson, the chief executive of MetLife. “If
someone profits from a stranger’s death, it stands the whole purpose of life
insurance on its head. Anything that disrupts the economic processes underlying
this industry will drive the cost of life insurance through the ceiling.”
Policies like Mr. Margolis’s cause particular concern. It was originally paid
for with a loan from speculators who will get their money back, plus a profit,
if it is sold to another group of investors, according to public documents.
Even if Mr. Margolis does not sell, the loan will be repaid from the death
benefit when he dies.
Such policies are known as speculator-initiated life insurance,
or “spin-life” policies. Investors estimate that spin-life policies worth as
much as $13 billion will change hands next year.
The deals are so lucrative that older people are being wooed in
every fathomable way. In Florida, investors have sponsored free cruises for
seniors willing to undergo physical exams and apply for life insurance while
onboard.
For insurers, such cruises are a financial Titanic. Over the
next decade, the insurance industry could be forced to pay out unexpectedly
more than $100 billion in death benefits as spin-life policies come to
maturity, investors estimate.
In Minnesota, according to lawsuits brought by insurers, an
82-year-old named John R. Paulson bought life policies worth $120 million from
seven companies and resold many of them before insurance companies realized
what was going on and sued, saying that Mr. Paulson had lied on his
applications.
Life insurance companies, in particular, rely on policies
lapsing before the policyholder dies. Last year, for instance, insurance
companies reduced their financial exposure by $1.1 trillion when 19.8 million
policyholders stopped paying premiums, according to the Insurance Information
Institute. In comparison, the industry paid death benefits on only 2.2 million
policies.
If those lapsed policies had been sold to investors rather than
canceled, insurance companies could have eventually paid out as much as a
trillion dollars, say analysts.
In an attempt to mitigate such risk, some insurance companies
are trying to make policies for seniors harder to buy. The biggest insurer in
the United States, American International Group, earlier this year increased
prices on some universal life policies for buyers more than 70 years old in an
effort to thwart spin-life deals.
“We don’t want this business, and we’re taking steps to
discourage those purchasers from coming through our doors,” an A.I.G. spokesman
said.
But such moves may be too late. The market for purchasing life insurance
policies from seniors is an outgrowth of the so-called viatical industry that
began in the 1980s, when investors bought up life insurance policies of AIDS
patients. In the last two years, as interest rates and stock market returns
have declined, the number of buyers seeking seniors’ policies has soared.
That growth was fueled this year when the Financial Accounting
Standards Board issued rules permitting investors to record purchases of
policies immediately as a profit, rather than forcing them to wait until the
policyholder died.
Critics contend the industry punishes the young and healthy, by
driving up prices, but many people who have sold their policies say it offered
their only way to avoid calamity.
“If I hadn’t been able to sell this policy we would have lost
our house, all of our savings, everything,” said Andrew Schneider of Kaysville,
Utah. Seven years ago his wife, Karen, learned she had breast cancer. Her
expenses exceeded the Schneiders’ medical insurance by half a million dollars.
Mrs. Schneider sold her life insurance policy for about $250,000 and used the
money to buy medicine and pay bills, he said. The investors who bought her
policy received a $500,000 death benefit when she died last year.
Golden Opportunities
Cashing In
Articles in this series will examine how businesses and
investors seek to profit from the soaring number of older Americans, in ways
helpful and harmful.
Multimedia
 Graphic
How Spin-Life Works
“Selling that policy extended her life for years,” said Mr.
Schneider. “If this market hadn’t existed, we would have become financially
destitute.”
Finding enough life insurance policies to satisfy investor
hunger has proved difficult. So, in addition to the free cruises in Florida,
investors including one large hedge fund have hired a California telemarketing
company to call elderly citizens and ask if they would apply for life insurance
in exchange for a paycheck.
The insurance industry has begun to fight back. Legislatures in
New Jersey, New York and nine other states have proposed laws intended to
outlaw spin-life investments or make it more difficult for investors to get
payouts, according to the Life Insurance Settlement Association.
Insurance companies have also sued to cancel policies,
contending that payouts benefiting outside investors violate the legal
requirement that beneficiaries have an “insurable interest” in the
policyholder’s life.
But many advocates for the elderly and industry insiders worry
that seniors will lose their legitimate ability to sell life insurance policies
they have held for years.
“We’ve put billions of dollars in the hands of seniors who were
getting thrown out of their homes or needed medication, and their only asset
was a life insurance policy,” said Scott Page, chief executive of the Lifeline
Program, a company that helps investors buy life insurance policies from the
elderly and infirm. “If you make it harder to sell these policies, you’re
taking money out of the hands of people who have nothing else.”
Another risk is that seniors hoping to sell their life insurance
policies will be stuck in bad deals. In October, the New York attorney general,
Eliot Spitzer, filed a lawsuit accusing one life insurance speculator, Coventry
Financial, of bid-rigging and other fraud in acquiring more than $3.6 billion
in life insurance policies. Coventry said it would fight the suit.
A lawyer who has helped the elderly set up spin-life
arrangements worth more than $300 million said that often the terms of the
deals prevented his clients from profiting.
“Investors say, ‘I’ll loan you money to buy a new policy, and in
a few years I’ll buy it from you,’ ” said Larry Brody, a partner at the law
firm Bryan Cave. But a few years later, when the seniors sell the policy, they
owe so much in interest and fees on the loan, he said, “it eats up all the
profit. And what’s more, they can’t buy another insurance policy, because
insurers are unwilling to give them more coverage.”
But those risks are worth the trouble, according to some buyers
and sellers. In 2004, Irene Randall, a life-settlement broker in Albuquerque,
N.M., set up an $8 million spin-life policy for her 82-year-old uncle with
investors who agreed to lend him money for the premiums. In return, she said,
the company hopes to buy the policy next year, paying her uncle $1.5 million.
Ms. Randall called it a great deal and said she was setting up a
similar arrangement for her 82-year-old mother. She expects both her mother and
uncle will live long enough to enjoy the windfall. “The one thing we know is
that everyone is going to die at some point,” said Ms. Randall. “If someone is
willing to pay you because you’re old, why not try and live it up before then?”
|